Legal Expertise
Investigations, Inquiries & Pre-Charge Advice
What Pre-Charge Advice Is
Pre charge advice is legal advice obtained during a criminal investigation, before any charge has been laid. It applies from the moment police make contact, a regulator sends a notice, or a summons arrives at the door. Most people assume that a lawyer becomes useful only once charges exist and a court date has been set. The opposite is closer to the truth, because the investigation period is when the evidence is still being gathered and no decision to charge has been made. It is also the point at which what a person says, or declines to say, carries the most weight. Slades + Parsons practises exclusively in criminal law and is led by LIV Accredited Criminal Law Specialists. The firm has acted for people under investigation for more than 35 years, and takes calls on (03) 9602 3000 at any hour.
How an Investigation Begins
An investigation can commence in several ways: a phone call, a formal letter, an unexpected visit from police, the execution of a search warrant, a regulatory notice, or a summons. Regardless of the trigger, the core legal question remains the same: what are your obligations, and what are your rights? The answer depends entirely on who is asking and the legal framework under which they are operating. These specifics dictate your critical next steps.
When Police Want to Interview You
Police may ask you to attend a record of interview, and the request is commonly framed as a chance to explain yourself. Attendance is sometimes voluntary where you have not been arrested, and the decision to participate is one to make with advice rather than at the counter. For indictable offences, attendance at an interview will usually be mandatory, and again, it is critical that advice is obtained beforehand. The interview itself is a formal process, and what is said in it can later be used in evidence against you. Slades + Parson’s record of interview advice page covers what happens in the room, what declining to answer means, and how the recording is used afterwards.
When IBAC or a Crime Commission Has Summonsed You
A summons from IBAC or a crime commission operates differently to a police investigation, because those bodies hold coercive powers. A person examined under those powers cannot decline to answer as they could with police, and the protections applying instead are narrower and more technical. Our IBAC and crime commissions page sets out how an examination proceeds and what happens to evidence given under compulsion.
When a Royal Commission or Inquiry Has Called You
A Royal Commission or public inquiry can require a person or an organisation to produce documents, provide a statement, or appear as a witness. The proceedings are public in most instances, and an adverse finding carries consequences that are reputational and professional rather than criminal. The firm’s royal commissions and inquiries page covers summonses, statement preparation, legal professional privilege and appearances.
The Right to Silence in Victoria
The right to silence applies in Victoria to police questioning, and the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) limits the inferences a court may draw from silence. That protection is not absolute, and it does not extend evenly across other jurisdictions or across compulsory examination powers. Certain obligations remain in any case, including the requirement to provide identifying details in particular circumstances. What applies to your situation depends on the power being exercised, and that distinction is the thing to establish before responding.
How Slades + Parsons Works in the Pre-Charge Period
The work in the pre charge period involves establishing what is being investigated and by whom, and communicating with investigators on your behalf. It extends to advising on whether to participate in an interview and preparing the material that supports your position. Where alternative pathways exist, they are identified and pursued at that stage rather than later. Matters are handled with discretion, because for many people under investigation the existence of the investigation is itself the risk.
Professionals and Organisations Under Investigation
For a registered professional, an investigation carries consequences that run alongside the criminal process rather than after it. A health practitioner regulated by AHPRA, a teacher, or a holder of a Working with Children Check may face notification obligations or regulatory conditions. Whether those obligations are invoked depends on the offence type and on the threshold set under the Worker Screening Act 2020 (Vic). Not every charge produces that result, and the thresholds differ by profession and by regulator. The same applies to organisations, where conduct within a workplace can move from an internal matter to a police investigation without much warning.
Search Warrants
A search warrant authorises police to enter and to seize, and the material seized frequently includes telephones, computers and documents that take months to examine. What is said during a search is recorded and becomes part of the material assembled against you. People commonly answer questions while a search is under way, on the assumption that cooperation will bring it to an end sooner.
Contact From a Regulator
Contact from a regulator is not the same as contact from police, and it carries its own powers to compel documents and answers. Notices from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission or the Australian Taxation Office commonly precede a criminal referral rather than follow one. Our white collar and financial crime page covers the offences those referrals lead to, and the tax fraud and tax evasion page covers ATO matters specifically.
When to Make Contact
The most useful point at which to obtain advice is the first contact, and before any response is given to the agency making it. Slades + Parsons takes calls on (03) 9602 3000 at any hour.
FAQs
-
In most circumstances, if you have been asked to attend voluntarily, you are not legally required to participate in Victoria. If you have been arrested, you retain the right to silence under Victorian law, though in some contexts specific obligations may still apply. Before agreeing to any interview – voluntary or otherwise – attendance is usually mandatory, but it is worth confirming with a criminal lawyer before agreeing to attend.
-
A record of interview (ROI) is a formal, recorded question-and-answer session between police and a person under investigation. Subject to admissibility rules, its contents may be used as evidence in subsequent Victorian court proceedings. Because participation carries significant legal risk, the decision about whether – and how – to engage must be made only after obtaining proper legal advice.
-
In some circumstances, early legal intervention assists. Engaging with investigators at the pre charge stage, establishing the direction of the case, and identifying alternative pathways can change how a matter resolves, although that depends entirely on the facts and is never guaranteed. The crucial point is that those options exist only while the charging decision is still open.
-
Potentially, yes. For professionals regulated by bodies such as AHPRA, or those subject to a Working with Children Check under the Worker Screening Act 2020 (Vic), certain charges may trigger notification obligations or regulatory consequences depending on the offence type, profession, and applicable statutory threshold. Not every charge triggers a consequence, and this can include interim conditions on registration rather than automatic suspension. Engaging a lawyer early allows you to understand those risks and take steps to manage them.
-
Immediately – and before responding to any police request. Police investigations move quickly, and the pre-charge window is finite. Slades & Parsons has a 24-hour emergency advice line for exactly these situations. Call (03) 9602 3000 as soon as police make contact, and before you agree to anything.
-
Pre-charge advice is legal advice obtained during a criminal investigation and before any charge has been laid. It covers police contact, requests to attend an interview, search warrants, regulator notices and summonses issued by investigative bodies. The purpose is to establish what is being investigated, what you are required to do, and what options exist while the charging decision remains open.
-
Legal advice before a record of interview is the single most useful step available during an investigation, because what is said in the interview can be used in evidence and cannot be withdrawn afterwards. Attendance is generally voluntary where a person has not been arrested. The decision about whether to attend, and about whether to answer questions, is one to make on advice rather than at the police station.
-
A search warrant authorises police to enter and to seize property, and the material taken commonly includes telephones, computers and documents. Examination of that material can take months, during which no charge may be laid. Anything said during the search is recorded and forms part of the investigation, and legal advice is available at that point rather than only once the search has concluded.
-
No. IBAC, the Australian Crime Commission, and similar investigative bodies hold coercive powers, which means a person examined under those powers cannot decline to answer in the way they could with police. Different protections apply to the evidence given, and legal representation at an examination is an entitlement. The consequences of answering, and the limits on how those answers can be used, are issues upon which careful advice is required before the examination date.
Chat To Our Team of Experts
Melbourne Office
Level 1,
224 Queen St,
Melbourne,
Victoria, 3000
Trending Insights To Be In The Loop