Frequently Asked Questions

Commonwealth Criminal Offences

  • The Federal Government has the power to create offences in areas where it has the authority to act. This includes control of the national borders, trade, taxation, social security and customs. A Commonwealth criminal offence is charged where there is a breach of the law of the Commonwealth, such as the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) or the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). The Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) governs the general principles of criminal liability for all federal offences. These matters are not prosecuted under state laws, and the prosecution is usually conducted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. Sentencing is largely governed by the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), and the court is required to consider consistency in sentencing across all jurisdictions.

  • The Australian Federal Police works with the Australian Taxation Office, Services Australia and other agencies to investigate and prosecute fraudulent activity. Commonwealth prosecutions of tax fraud are common, with a focus on GST frauds. Avoidance of excise duties on imported alcohol and tobacco products is also frequently prosecuted. Social security prosecutions are a significant area of focus, covering overpayment, failure to disclose relevant information, and fraudulent receipt of government benefits. False statements made to obtain a benefit, failing to declare income, and being employed while receiving a benefit may all attract prosecution.

  • Commonwealth drug offences are usually associated with the importation of illicit drugs, and they range from matters involving small quantities of a border-controlled substance to large importations. Offences involving a marketable quantity carry a maximum penalty of 25 years imprisonment, and offences involving a commercial quantity carry a maximum of life imprisonment. The quantity thresholds vary by substance. The charge is frequently an attempt to import or an attempt to possess, because the substance has been intercepted and substituted before delivery. The Commonwealth also prosecutes offences involving precursor chemicals and other border-controlled substances such as steroids.

  • The two indicators are the investigating agency and the legislation cited on the charge. Where the Australian Federal Police, the Australian Border Force, ASIC, the Australian Taxation Office or Services Australia conducted the investigation, the matter is likely to be federal. Where the charge cites the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) or another Commonwealth Act rather than Victorian legislation, it is federal. Commonwealth charges are prosecuted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions.

  • The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions conducts prosecutions for federal offences, and the Office of Public Prosecutions conducts prosecutions for Victorian offences. The CDPP applies its own published prosecution policy when deciding which charges proceed and whether to accept representations to withdraw or reduce them. A person can face charges from both in the same matter, where the alleged conduct breaches both federal and state law.

  • No. Commonwealth criminal matters are heard in state courts exercising federal jurisdiction, which in Victoria means the Magistrates’ Court, the County Court and the Supreme Court. Less serious federal offences are dealt with summarily and serious matters proceed on indictment. What differs from a state prosecution is the legislation, the prosecuting authority and the sentencing regime, rather than the courthouse.

  • A recognisance release order is a Commonwealth sentencing option under the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) that allows a sentence of imprisonment to be served in the community on conditions, including good behaviour and, in some cases, supervision or the payment of a security. It has no exact equivalent in Victorian sentencing. Whether one is available depends on the offence, the length of the sentence and the circumstances of the person being sentenced.