What is a Committal Hearing?

Facing a serious criminal charge can be an overwhelming experience, especially when the legal process ahead feels unfamiliar. One of the first major stages in Victoria’s court system for indictable offences is the committal hearing. While the term may sound straightforward, its role within the criminal justice process is often misunderstood.

A committal hearing forms part of broader committal proceedings, which act as a preliminary filter before a case is sent to the County Court or Supreme Court for trial. Understanding this step and how it can shape the course of a case is crucial when navigating serious charges.

How Committal Hearings Work

When someone is charged with an indictable offence in Victoria, their case doesn’t proceed straight to trial. Instead, it begins in the Magistrates’ Court. Before it can be transferred to a higher court, a magistrate must first assess whether the prosecution has presented enough evidence to justify putting the accused on trial. This assessment occurs during the committal hearing.

The committal hearing is usually the final stage of a series of procedural steps, including a filing hearing, committal mention, and committal case conference. These steps help manage timelines, encourage early resolution, and clarify whether any witnesses should be cross-examined. At the hearing itself, the magistrate reviews the prosecution’s brief of evidence, considers any witness cross-examinations (if permitted), and hears legal submissions from both sides.

It’s not a trial, and there’s no jury. The magistrate’s job is to determine whether the evidence, taken at its highest, could support a conviction. If so, the matter is committed to trial in a higher court. If not, the accused is discharged.

Why Committal Hearings Matter

For the defence, committal hearings can be strategically valuable. They offer a first opportunity to review the prosecution’s case in full, challenge weak or inconsistent evidence, and identify potential issues ahead of trial. In some cases, the process can lead to a resolution – whether that’s a withdrawal of charges, a reduction in severity, or even a guilty plea to lesser offences.

These hearings are also important for ensuring fairness. They help the accused understand the case against them, support proper trial preparation, and allow both parties to narrow the issues in dispute. For this reason, committal proceedings play a crucial role in upholding the integrity of Victoria’s criminal justice system.

When Committal Hearings Don’t Apply

Not every serious offence goes through a committal hearing. Certain matters, particularly sexual offences involving children or people with cognitive impairments, must proceed directly to a higher court without a committal. Similarly, if an accused person decides to waive their right to a committal hearing, the case can move straight to trial or sentencing, depending on the plea.

These decisions should never be made lightly and always with legal advice. The strategic benefit of a committal hearing can vary greatly depending on the circumstances of the case.

Next Steps After a Committal Hearing

If the magistrate commits the case for trial, it will be transferred to the County Court or Supreme Court, where it will continue through the standard pre-trial and trial process. However, if the evidence is found to be insufficient, the accused is discharged, and the charges are dismissed unless new evidence emerges.

Even when the case proceeds, the committal hearing often shapes the tone and direction of the trial to follow. What’s uncovered or clarified at this stage can make a significant difference to the outcome.

Need Legal Advice Before a Committal Hearing

The committal hearing stage plays a critical role in Victoria’s criminal court process. It can shape the course of a case, influence plea decisions, and impact whether the matter proceeds to trial at all.

If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges, early legal advice is essential. Our experienced team of criminal defence lawyers in Melbourne can help you understand your options, protect your rights, and develop a strategy tailored to your situation.

To discuss your case in confidence, contact us today. We’re here to help you navigate the process with clarity, expertise, and strong legal representation.

Note: Significant reforms to committal hearings are scheduled for November 2025. This article discusses the current process. We’ll update this page once the reforms take effect.